Photo: Why I will hand back my degree to McGill University

Viola Ng via Flickr

By Karel Mayrand, Director General for Quebec

Twenty-one years ago, I finished my last exam and left the McGill University campus for the last time. I remember how proud I felt. As someone from the small town of Rimouski, Quebec, where we rarely heard a word of English, graduating from McGill felt like conquering Mount Everest.

Sign up for our newsletter

I will always remember the words of Elie Wiesel, the keynote speaker at my graduation: "The opposite of love is not hate. It is indifference." This was his way of telling us that our degree came with responsibility — the responsibility not to turn away in the face of moral peril, to stand up for what is right. These words are among the greatest gifts I was ever offered.

Climate change is the defining issue of our times. It is a scientific fact. Acting to prevent it is not only a technological, economic and political challenge, it has become a moral imperative. In his 2015 encyclical, Laudato Si, Pope Francis said environmental destruction comes from the same evil that leads to social destruction: moral relativity. He reminded us that climate change will first and foremost hurt the poorest, and that we share a responsibility to protect the Creation.

Working with David Suzuki for several years, I have learned that the biosphere is our only home, and that life on Earth is an extraordinary thing. There is strong scientific consensus that global warming beyond 2 C above pre-industrial level is dangerous. We are on a path that will lead to warming above 4 C. This threatens the very foundation of our civilization and could throw Earth's life-support systems off track for millennia.

Can we stay indifferent in the face of such peril? I can't, and this is why I will hand back my degree to McGill University.

Two-thirds of all fossil fuels — coal, oil, gas — need to stay in the ground to avoid dangerous warming. Here's the catch: the current value of fossil fuel assets is based on full exploitation of all proven reserves. The only way for these assets to maintain their value is to burn all these reserves and trigger catastrophic climate change. If we act to protect our climate, they lose their value and become "stranded assets". Investors have a moral decision to make: either help protect our climate or go after short-term gains.

According to publicly accessible information, McGill University holds approximately $70 million in fossil fuel investments, or roughly five per cent of its $1.3 billion endowment fund. When it invests part of its endowment fund in coal, oil and gas, McGill University is betting on fossil fuels against our climate. This is an example of the moral relativity Pope Francis is warning us against, and of the indifference to human harm Elie Wiesel so eloquently talked about at my graduation.

Dozens of universities in the world, including Stanford and Oxford, have announced that they will divest. In doing so, they are not only making an ethical decision, they are also protecting their assets by reducing exposure to what economists are now calling a carbon bubble.

The time has come for McGill University to do the right thing. Indifference is no longer an option on climate change. As one of Canada's greatest scientific and educational institutions, McGill University has the opportunity to show leadership, integrity and vision.

Unfortunately, McGill has chosen to reject divestment, and as a result I will hand back my degree on April 1. I encourage all alumni to join me and the McGill Alumni for Divestment to make fossil fuels investments a thing of the past at McGill:

Karel Mayrand is the David Suzuki Foundation's Director General for Quebec, Chair of Al Gore's Climate Reality Project Canada and a Proud McGill University alumnus.

April 1, 2016

Post a comment


Apr 03, 2016
12:23 AM

Who does this on april 1!?!?

Apr 02, 2016
8:44 PM

And why they don’t want to divest ? Is it because someone is friend with a someone who own fossil fuels?

Apr 02, 2016
6:35 PM

Excellent decision. I wish even one of the “engineers” working on BC Hydro’s Site C dam and powerplant in BC had the moral courage to say “enough”! BC Hydro in its own resource plan, identified conservation as the most favorable choice, ie reduce waste — enough to more than supply the additional electricity for the next 10 years! At less cost and with double the number of jobs, saving precious farmland, while reducing CO2 and methane emissions. But not one BC Liberal, even NDP, or Green Party politician even has the courage to LEAD! Out of this morass into harmony with First Nations, farmers, ecologists and ratepayers. RB

Apr 02, 2016
4:52 PM

I am far more disturbed that our society allows the elderly, sick, disabled and unborn to be sacrificed on the altar of selfishness, self-indulgence, greed and, yes, indifference. Until society learns to value and protect those made in the image of God do not expect it to do so for a planet.

Apr 01, 2016
8:43 PM

Although i am a car loving guy, i can see that we cant go on this way very much longer. Unfortunately, the powers that be are so solidly tied into fossil fuels that It would take a major happening to make them back off. I think we are a pox on the world anyway. It took us less than 100 years to mess up something precious. The thing that really matters is thaawe seem not to care about what we leave future generations. This is hedonism at its peak. We need to recognize megalomania as a real disease. The CEO`s of most major companies are megalomaniacs. With what they are doing to our ecology they severely need help. If they are intelligent individuals they may realize what they need to do before it is too late. Only time will tell and there is not much of it left.

Apr 01, 2016
5:51 PM

”[…] and a Proud McGill University ” … I hope you now mean EX-alumnus because after handing back your degree you essentially do not have on your degree, in whatever domain it is, and not should you claim you have any university education.

70 million dollars is a lot of money but compared to the market capitalization of that sector of the economy, it is negligible! Why should McGill loose an opportunity to make money to improve the aging buildings because a few “tree huggers” think this amount of money will change the world’s climate.

Ironic though that Karel decided to hand back his degree on April 1st (April fools day). Perhaps only a fool would do something like this and hand back a degree.

I stand by McGill’s decision!

Apr 01, 2016
5:26 PM

Since it’s April Fools, I find it difficult to take this article as fact. But I don’t find it hard to believe that investment has been made in the fossil fuel industry from people of a different era.

Apr 01, 2016
5:22 PM

Not sure if this is true or a joke.

The David Suzuki Foundation does not necessarily endorse the comments or views posted within this forum. All contributors acknowledge DSF's right to remove product/service endorsements and refuse publication of comments deemed to be offensive or that contravene our operating principles as a charitable organization. Please note that all comments are pre-moderated. Privacy Policy »